{"id":4813,"date":"2019-02-06T11:04:38","date_gmt":"2019-02-06T11:04:38","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/?p=4813"},"modified":"2019-07-12T13:22:30","modified_gmt":"2019-07-12T13:22:30","slug":"isnt-all-trauma-cultural","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/2019\/02\/06\/isnt-all-trauma-cultural\/","title":{"rendered":"Isn&rsquo;t ALL trauma &lsquo;cultural&rsquo;?"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>In a recent post I introduced <a href=\"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/2018\/12\/17\/brexit-as-trauma\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener noreferrer\">Jeffery Alexander\u2019s idea of cultural trauma<\/a> which occurs when members of a social group feel they have been subjected to an horrendous event, which changes their sense of group consciousness, memory and future identity in a fundamental and irrevocable way.\u00a0 What\u2019s critical to note here is that Alexander refers to an \u2018horrendous event\u2019 rather than \u2018trauma\u2019; and this is because the trauma itself is the product of an elaborate cultural process.<\/p>\n<p>As I pointed out in <a href=\"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/2018\/12\/18\/brexit-as-trauma-part-2\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener noreferrer\">my subsequent post<\/a>, Alexander appears to be making a differentiation between <em>cultural<\/em> and <em>individual<\/em> trauma.\u00a0 This is not explicitly spelt out in his argument, but he does appear to conflate \u2018cultural\u2019 with \u2018social\u2019, and his focus is on collectivities rather than individuals.\u00a0 However, in my view this misses the point entirely because the idea that a culture can be \u2018traumatised\u2019 makes no sense.\u00a0 This is because \u2018culture\u2019 is precisely the system of representation and meaning that makes the concept of trauma possible in the first place.\u00a0 Far more problematic, in fact, is the concept of the &#8216;individual&#8217;, which is often another way of describing the &#8216;self&#8217; or the &#8216;ego&#8217;. Both self and ego are essentially the product of Imaginary identifications with a range of specular others.<\/p>\n<p>Perhaps the real issue here is that the term \u2018trauma\u2019 actually has two very different meanings, although as we shall see they are still related to one another.\u00a0 Firstly, trauma is a <em>manifestation of the Real<\/em>, as Lacan makes clear in Seminar XI. <sup><a href=\"#footnote_1_4813\" id=\"identifier_1_4813\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"Lacan, J. (1979) The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psycho-Analysis. London: Penguin.\">1<\/a><\/sup>\u00a0 Used this way, trauma is something that is &#8216;beyond&#8217; or &#8216;outside&#8217; of representation; something which makes no sense to the subject. There are number of problems here, however, including the idea that the Real is a function of language itself.<\/p>\n<p>Secondly, trauma can be seen as a <em>narrative<\/em>, which is constructed retroactively and which brings us back to the idea of Freud\u2019s <em>Nachtr\u00e4glichkeit.\u00a0 <\/em>The complication here is that such a trauma narrative has traumatic effects itself, for reasons I will come to shortly.\u00a0\u00a0 The key point here is that, in this sense, <em>all<\/em> trauma is a construction; and the process of constructing such a trauma narrative is <em>cultural<\/em>.\u00a0 This applies as much to the \u2018trauma work\u2019 that takes place in the therapist\u2019s consulting room as it does to histories of the Holocaust.\u00a0 Both are attempts to represent and make sense of events and experiences which are essentially beyond meaning.<\/p>\n<p>But if trauma is a cultural construction, does it make sense to speak of an \u2018original trauma\u2019, which is often thought of as being located in early childhood and (quite often) rooted in some form of sexual encounter?\u00a0 On the other hand, of course, such an \u2018original\u2019 trauma can be an event such as the Holocaust, which whilst not rooted in the early life of a particular individual, is still none the less beyond comprehension.\u00a0 In either case, though, the question of \u2018origin\u2019 looms large.<\/p>\n<p>The idea of an \u2018origin\u2019 only makes sense within a discursive framework.\u00a0 Furthermore, there has to be an \u2018anchoring point\u2019 in order to construct such a framework; or, to be more precise in this particular case, in order to construct a historical (trauma) narrative that has a \u2018beginning\u2019 (if not an \u2018end\u2019).\u00a0 And if we are to take the idea of <em>Nachtr\u00e4glichkeit<\/em> seriously then it\u2019s clear that such a narrative can only be constructed <em>retroactively<\/em>, which includes its \u2018origin\u2019.\u00a0 This is what led Lacan to argue that rather than the subject\u2019s future being determined by his past, it was the other way round; the subject\u2019s past is determined by his future.<\/p>\n<p>Clearly this goes against any \u2018common sense\u2019 notions of temporality and causality; how can the future \u2018determine\u2019 the past?\u00a0 The key point to remember here is that ideas of temporality, causality, \u2018past\u2019, \u2018present\u2019 and \u2018future\u2019, only make sense within a symbolic framework.\u00a0 But even if we accept this idea of a retroactively constructed \u2018original trauma\u2019, surely this is not to suggest that nothing actually happened?\u00a0 On the contrary, something certainly <em>did<\/em> happen; the problem is trying to work out what this \u2018something\u2019 is.<\/p>\n<p>At this point I would like to hypothesise that rather than looking for an \u2018original trauma\u2019, it would be more helpful to think of history in terms of writing the Real into the Symbolic.\u00a0 This not only gets round the problem of an &#8216;original&#8217; traumatic event or experience, but also helps explain how trauma narratives can have traumatic effects.\u00a0 The &#8216;original trauma&#8217; is essentially a Real Event; one that can only become historicised through a retroactive, symbolic process. This process is the &#8216;trauma work&#8217;, the construction of a trauma narrative.<\/p>\n<p>But is <em>every<\/em> Event traumatic? In one sense yes, because until it is codified, articulated, given meaning, it remains in the Real. Of course, in most cases this process of representation, giving meaning to something, happens very quickly and often unconsciously. Sometimes though, the experience is so strange and peculiar that it can take longer to &#8216;process&#8217; &#8211; if indeed it can be processed at all.<\/p>\n<p>What I&#8217;m essentially arguing here is that all history is based on the construction of trauma narratives.\u00a0 This is because such narratives represent a writing of the Real into the Symbolic, and every Event (human experience) is Real until it becomes thus written. The complication with this argument is that it doesn&#8217;t appear to explain why trauma narratives themselves can be traumatic.\u00a0 In fact, this argument appears to suggest that it is only when an Event is written into the Symbolic that it can have traumatic effects.\u00a0 In that case, how are we to explain, for example, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), in which the symptoms are (taken to be) the result of &#8216;unprocessed&#8217; trauma?<\/p>\n<p>The point about PTSD, though, is that the &#8216;symptoms&#8217; are actually manifestations of the Real (flashbacks, panic attacks, nightmares, etc).\u00a0 The treatment of PTSD essentially involves the construction of a trauma narrative, a way to try and &#8216;make sense&#8217; of what happened.\u00a0 However, my argument is that within that trauma narrative is a traumatic (Real) core. What further complicates the argument is whether PTSD itself is a form of (rudimentary) trauma narrative; in other words, has there already been some initial &#8216;processing&#8217; of the experiences which is enough to traumatise the subject? This might help explain the &#8216;delayed reaction&#8217; of PTSD, which can sometimes take years or even decades to manifest itself.<\/p>\n<p>Perhaps if we take this argument to its logical conclusion, then could it be argued that the \u2018past\u2019 itself is Real?\u00a0 In one sense, yes, insofar as the &#8216;past&#8217; is simply that which is not written, not articulated or given meaning.\u00a0 As soon as the &#8216;past&#8217; is written it becomes history.\u00a0 But in that case,\u00a0 what about the different <em>types<\/em> of history; for example, of individuals, societies, etc?\u00a0 In other words, if the &#8216;past&#8217; is just one, undifferentiated Real, how is it that different histories can be written from it?<\/p>\n<p>In fact, though, this is not such a problem.\u00a0 If the Real can be conceptualised in terms of isolated signifiers, which is Tom Eyers\u2019 argument, then the work of history is essentially about &#8216;writing&#8217; these isolated signifiers into various Symbolic formations, networks of meaning. <sup><a href=\"#footnote_2_4813\" id=\"identifier_2_4813\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-identifier-link\" title=\"Eyers, T. (2012) Lacan and the Concept of the &lsquo;Real&rsquo;. Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.\">2<\/a><\/sup> Therefore, the history of an individual and the history of a whole society are simply two different Symbolic articulations. However, one of the problems with such an argument is that it suggests that human subjects themselves are simply a particular form of Symbolic articulation, which, of course, is essentially the Lacanian position.<\/p>\n<p>However, even if the human <em>subject<\/em> is a Symbolic articulation, it does not follow that the human <em>being<\/em> is.\u00a0 And this is why the Real matters so much.\u00a0 Although on the one hand it can be seen as a traumatic disturbance in the fabric of human and social existence (what we like to call \u2018reality\u2019), on the other hand it represents a dimension of human existence that escapes the \u2018determinism\u2019 of the Symbolic.<\/p>\n<p>Going back to the original question: is <em>all<\/em> trauma cultural?\u00a0 The short answer is yes and no.\u00a0 Yes in the sense that all trauma narratives are cultural products, including those that emerge in the confines of the therapist\u2019s consulting room.\u00a0 In other words, all trauma, as narrative, as a product of <em>Nachtr\u00e4glichkeit<\/em>, is produced through a (cultural) process which involves giving meaning to the experience.\u00a0 No, in the sense that trauma is a manifestation of the Real, and to this extent is \u2018outside\u2019 or \u2018beyond\u2019 the network of signification.\u00a0 However, the complication here is that such a manifestation of the Real can only take place within the trauma narrative itself.\u00a0 In other words, the Real is a function of the Symbolic; but only <em>retroactively<\/em>, after it has been \u2018written\u2019 into the Symbolic itself.<\/p>\n<ol class=\"footnotes\"><li id=\"footnote_1_4813\" class=\"footnote\">Lacan, J. (1979) <i>The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psycho-Analysis<\/i>. London: Penguin.<span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\">[<a href=\"#identifier_1_4813\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\">&#8617;<\/a>]<\/span><\/li><li id=\"footnote_2_4813\" class=\"footnote\">Eyers, T. (2012) <i>Lacan and the Concept of the \u2018Real\u2019<\/i>. Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.<span class=\"footnote-back-link-wrapper\">[<a href=\"#identifier_2_4813\" class=\"footnote-link footnote-back-link\">&#8617;<\/a>]<\/span><\/li><\/ol>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>In a recent post I introduced Jeffery Alexander\u2019s idea of cultural trauma which occurs when members of a social group feel they have been subjected to an horrendous event, which changes their sense of group consciousness, memory and future identity in a fundamental and irrevocable way.\u00a0 What\u2019s critical to note &hellip;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_acf_changed":false,"inline_featured_image":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[20],"tags":[327,126,180,281,266],"class_list":["post-4813","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-trauma-history-and-memory","tag-cultural-trauma","tag-history","tag-nachtraglichkeit","tag-real","tag-trauma"],"acf":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4813","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=4813"}],"version-history":[{"count":3,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4813\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":5038,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4813\/revisions\/5038"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=4813"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=4813"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=4813"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}