{"id":5375,"date":"2022-05-25T16:56:53","date_gmt":"2022-05-25T15:56:53","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/?p=5375"},"modified":"2022-06-01T11:36:43","modified_gmt":"2022-06-01T10:36:43","slug":"the-premature-death-of-the-war-neuroses","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/2022\/05\/25\/the-premature-death-of-the-war-neuroses\/","title":{"rendered":"The premature death of the war neuroses"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>In September 1918 a Symposium was held at the Fifth International Psycho-Analytical Congress in Budapest on the subject of the war neuroses. S\u00e1ndor Ferenczi, Karl Abraham and Ernst Simmel all presented papers on this topic, and Freud himself wrote the introduction to the proceedings of the Symposium which were published in <em>Psycho-Analysis and the War Neuroses<\/em> in 1921.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-1\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-1\">[1]<\/a><\/sup> As Pedro Mu\u00f1oz and S\u00edlvia Correia note in their discussion of the Congress and its significance in the wider context of psychoanalysis in the second decade of the twentieth century, these lectures attracted a great deal of interest from the military medical authorities representing the Central Powers.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-2\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-2\">[2]<\/a><\/sup> And at the time it appeared that a bright future lay ahead for a psychoanalytic understanding of, and a clinical engagement with, the psychical traumas of war.<\/p>\n<p>However, it was not to be. Instead, the next sixty years or so saw a progressive disengagement of psychoanalysis from the theory and treatment of the war neuroses, culminating in the disappearance of the term completely from the psychiatric literature and the emergence of a completely new paradigm of trauma in the aftermath of the Vietnam War: post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). I will have more to say later on about this disengagement and the appearance of PTSD, but I would like to begin by returning to the Budapest Symposium and its hopes for a psychoanalytic future, especially with regards to the understanding and treatment of the war neuroses.<\/p>\n<p>The first thing to note is that the term \u2018war neurosis\u2019 (or, more precisely, \u2018the war neuroses\u2019) were regarded by Freud and his colleagues as a form of <em>traumatic neurosis<\/em>. This is made clear by Freud in his introduction to the proceedings of the Symposium, and the term \u2018traumatic neuroses\u2019 is used a number of times by both Ferenczi and Abraham in their presentations.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-3\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-3\">[3]<\/a><\/sup> Somewhat confusingly, perhaps, Freud and Abraham both refer to \u2018the traumatic neuroses of peace time\u2019 but not \u2018the traumatic neuroses of war (time)\u2019, opting instead for the term \u2018the war neuroses\u2019 or simply \u2018war neurosis\u2019. This might suggest that they are referring to two different phenomena, that is, the traumatic neuroses (of peace) and the war neuroses, but it is clear from their texts that these terms are equivalent. However, this does raise the question as to whether there is something different or extra-ordinary about the conditions of war as opposed to the conditions of peace which might result in a different form of psychopathology.<\/p>\n<p>I only mention this because one of the reasons for the demise of psychoanalysis as a way to engage with \u2018life-traumas\u2019 (of which war is a particularly extreme example) is precisely that it appeared to lack a theoretical framework that would accommodate these types of events. In other words, childhood sexuality and the Oedipal drama appeared to have nothing to do with the traumas of being bombed, shelled, machine gunned, raped or carted off to a concentration camp. And yet, at the time of the Budapest Symposium, this was <em>precisely<\/em> what Ferenczi and his colleagues <em>were<\/em> arguing. In fact, one of the dominant themes of the Symposium was to challenge the idea, which was widespread in psychiatric circles, that the war neuroses had \u2018disproved\u2019 Freud\u2019s theories, and especially those related to infantile sexuality.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-4\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-4\">[4]<\/a><\/sup><\/p>\n<p>In many ways it\u2019s perhaps unfortunate that the Symposium predated Freud\u2019s <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle<\/em>, where he introduces the idea of the death drive.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-5\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-5\">[5]<\/a><\/sup> At least then the participants in the Symposium would have had a psychoanalytic theory that could directly confront the question of human aggression and destructiveness. On the other hand, the concept of the death drive turned out to be even more unpalatable, including for many psychoanalysts, than the idea of infantile sexuality itself. The other point, of course, is that the Symposium was trying to address the (psychical) <em>consequences<\/em> of the death drive, of human destructive, rather than its <em>causes<\/em>.<\/p>\n<p>The basic thrust of the argument of all the Symposium\u2019s participants was that the war neuroses were the product of an underlying psychopathology that was rooted in unresolved, childhood sexual conflicts. In other words, those who were suffering from war neurosis were already neurotic.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-6\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-6\">[6]<\/a><\/sup> For example, Simmel argues that:<\/p>\n<blockquote><p>The psycho-analytical explanation of the war neuroses has proved with wonderful clearness the correctness of the Freudian views on hysteria, according to which all physical symptoms represent conversions of something psychical. The body is the instrument of the mind upon which it (the mind) allows its unconscious to manifest itself in plastic and mimic expression. The functions of the unconscious are the deciding factor in the formation and building up of the war neuroses, also the frequently observed instances of the forgetting of events accompanied by feelings hostile to the ego, even when these events are very recent, permits us to recognise from the outside alone the submergence and repression of ideas and affects of a painful nature.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-7\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-7\">[7]<\/a><\/sup><\/p><\/blockquote>\n<p>Ferenczi, Abraham, Jones (in his separate paper) and Freud (in his Introduction) all follow a similar line: the traumatic experiences of war \u2018trigger\u2019 an underlying psychopathology, often hysterical in nature. Just to give one more example, Abraham, in somewhat condescending language, argues that: \u201cIt transpires with great regularity that the war neurotics already before the trauma were labile people\u2014to designate it, to begin with, by a general expression\u2014and especially so as regards their sexuality.\u201d<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-8\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-8\">[8]<\/a><\/sup> By \u2018labile\u2019 he appears to mean \u2018emotionally volatile\u2019 and which he seems to view as a weakness (in men at least). And herein, perhaps, lie the seeds of destruction for a psychoanalytic approach to the war neuroses: the idea that some people have a \u2018disposition\u2019 towards trauma (because of their underlying psychopathology) whereas other, \u2018normal\u2019, subjects do not. However, it is also important to note that even today, a century after the Congress and its Symposium, it still has to be explained why not everyone who has experienced a \u2018traumatic\u2019 life event goes onto to develop traumatic symptoms; in other words, what determines whether a person will become traumatised or not when faced with a particular event?<\/p>\n<p>Certainly, at the time of the Budapest Symposium the idea of an underlying \u2018disposition\u2019 towards war neuroses was taken very seriously. However, and somewhat ironically (as Freud notes in his Introduction), the cessation of hostilities two months after the Congress also put an end to the opportunity to study the war neuroses. What Freud seems to be suggesting here, although he does not elaborate, is that the War was providing an ample supply of \u2018case material\u2019, in hospitals and other health facilities, which could be examined in some detail. Once the War had ended, this \u2018material\u2019 rapidly dissipated, and would probably not reappear, even years later, in (mainly private) psychoanalytic clinics.<\/p>\n<p>Furthermore, as Mu\u00f1oz and Correia, whom I cited earlier, point out, although the Congress came up with a number of concrete proposals to increase access to psychoanalysis, both for the military and the wider public, as well as appointing Ferenczi as president of the International Psychoanalytic Association (IPA), politics soon intervened in the form of the \u2018white terror\u2019 \u2013 the overthrow of the communist government of B\u00e9la Kun in Hungary by Admiral Mikl\u00f3s Horthy in 1919 who imposed strict anti-semitic laws regarding the number of Jewish students and professors at universities. This resulted in Ferenczi, who was himself Jewish, having to relinquish his position to Jones and, perhaps more damaging for psychoanalysis as a whole, meant that many psychoanalysts had to retreat from public life and practice, which was accompanied by the dismantling of the Hungarian Psychoanalytic Association.<\/p>\n<p>Clearly, such setbacks did not mean that psychoanalysis as a whole was a doomed enterprise, but they do illustrate how the vagaries of war and politics can have both a positive and negative influence on clinical practice and innovation.<sup><a id=\"post-5375-footnote-ref-9\" href=\"#post-5375-footnote-9\">[9]<\/a><\/sup> The War provided an opportunity for Freud and his colleagues to study the effects of psychical trauma in a relatively controlled environment and on an industrial scale, and to further develop their theory of the neuroses. It also meant, as is often the case in war time, that the medical and military authorities were more open to new and innovative ideas. By the same token, however, when the political and military situation changed so did the fortunes of psychoanalysis.<\/p>\n<p>But putting all these considerations to one side, perhaps what\u2019s really important here is the idea that the traumas of war \u2013 and by extrapolation all other extra-ordinary \u2018life events\u2019 \u2013 may be related in some way to individual psychopathology. In the current era of PTSD and the broader <a href=\"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/2022\/01\/20\/the-two-discourses-of-trauma\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">\u2018mental health\u2019 discourse of trauma<\/a> such an idea is total anathema, but as I indicated earlier, at the time this was taken very seriously amongst the analytic community and the military medical authorities. With regards to the \u2018invention\u2019 of PTSD, <a href=\"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/tag\/ptsd-2\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">this is something I have explored in some detail elsewhere<\/a>. However, the key point to note here is that within the mental health discourse of trauma there is no room (or need) for individual psychopathology; in other words, the question of \u2018disposition\u2019 becomes irrelevant. Instead, trauma is something that \u2018happens\u2019 to the subject and they have no \u2018responsibility\u2019 for their predicament whatsoever.<\/p>\n<p>In Lacanian terms it could be argued that within the mental health discourse of trauma, trauma is the \u2018fault\u2019 of the Other; whether the Other be another person or group of people, or something vaguer and more abstract \u2018out there\u2019 in the world. In the case of the Great War (and other wars and conflicts since), the Other could be the (often unseen) \u2018enemy\u2019, or equally the politicians \u2018back home\u2019 who started the war in the first place, or the blundering generals in hiding in their chateaus safely behind the lines who keep ordering their troops forward oblivious of the consequences. At this point it is important to note that even during the Great War itself such sentiments were widespread on all sides. Disillusionment with leaders, both military and political, and sense of betrayal were key factors in the revolutionary fervour that swept through Russia, Germany, Austria-Hungary and other countries in the latter stages of the War and its aftermath. And even in the (militarily) \u2018victorious\u2019 nations, and especially France and Britain, there was an equal sense of disillusionment and betrayal. Furthermore, as Mu\u00f1oz and Correia point out in their paper, Freud himself, although initially a supporter of the war, eventually became opposed to it. This being the case, it raises the question as to why the idea of a \u2018disposition\u2019 towards war neuroses ever gained traction in the first place.<\/p>\n<p>Some clues as to the motivation for promoting the idea of such a \u2018disposition\u2019 are provided in Mu\u00f1oz and Correia\u2019s paper. They note that both Ferenczi and Abraham had had the opportunity to observe traumatised soldiers at close quarters; Ferenczi became head of the department for neurology at the M\u00e1ria Val\u00e9ria Military Hospital where he was able to indulge his interest in the traumatic neuroses, and Abraham became director at the Allenstein Hospital where he was able to observe many cases of war neurosis. Ernst Simmel, the other key contributor at the Budapest Symposium, had been physician in charge at the Military Hospital of Posen where he had gained experience of the war neuroses. So clearly there was already a great deal of interest in the topic within analytic circles.<\/p>\n<p>There was also the question, which again is highlighted in Mu\u00f1oz and Correia\u2019s paper, of a pre-existing hostility towards psychoanalysis within the medical profession (and the wider society) and especially the idea of infantile sexuality. As I indicated earlier, the Symposium was an ideal opportunity for Freud and his colleagues to challenge those who claimed the war neuroses disproved the idea of a sexual aetiology of the neuroses. In other words, the Congress and its Symposium allowed Freud and colleagues the chance to further the cause of psychoanalysis in general.<\/p>\n<p>This does not mean, however, that they were wrong to argue for a \u2018disposition\u2019 towards war neuroses per se; rather, I would argue that they somewhat missed the point as to what \u2018disposition\u2019 actually meant in the first place. The essence of their argument was that <em>some<\/em> individuals were \u2018predisposed\u2019 towards war neuroses because they were already neurotic; the war experience simply \u2018triggered\u2019 what was there already. The implication here, of course, is that other people are <em>not<\/em> \u2018predisposed\u2019; in other words, they are \u2018normal\u2019, have \u2018strong egos\u2019, are more \u2018resilient\u2019, and so forth. This is certainly the tone of Ferenczi, Abraham and Simmel\u2019s presentations, and in retrospect could be seen as sounding the death-knell for a psychoanalytic theory of war neurosis in particular and traumatic neurosis in general.<\/p>\n<p>But as I indicated just now, this is to miss the point entirely, which is that we are <em>all<\/em> \u2018predisposed\u2019 to trauma. Ironically, this mirrors <em>precisely<\/em> the argument of those who argue <em>against<\/em> \u2018predisposition\u2019 and who subscribe to the mental health discourse of trauma.. Their argument is that <em>anyone<\/em> can become traumatised given the right (external) circumstances. My argument is the same; the only difference is that the source of the trauma is \u2018internal\u2019 rather than \u2018external\u2019 \u2013 and even then it\u2019s not quite so simple. What I\u2019m getting at here is that we are <em>all<\/em> susceptible to the jouissance of the drive, which is the source of the subject\u2019s trauma. And interestingly, although the mental health discourse of trauma argues that the subject is traumatised by \u2018external\u2019 forces or events, it still explains the traumatisation process itself as \u2018internal\u2019 or, to be more precise, as cognitive. According to this argument, the subject is traumatised because they cannot \u2018process\u2019 the traumatic experience; in other words, the experience is traumatic because it is senseless. And the solution to this lack of sense is to construct a trauma narrative which allows the subject to \u2018internalise\u2019 the experience.<\/p>\n<p>According to the mental health discourse of trauma, therefore, the subjective experience of trauma lies in the domain of <em>meaning<\/em> (or, rather, the <em>lack<\/em> of meaning). In Lacanian terms, this is in the register of the <em>Real<\/em>. Therefore the \u2018solution\u2019 to a lack of meaning is to <em>create<\/em> meaning in the form of the trauma narrative, which is in the realm of the <em>Imaginary<\/em>. However, the register of the Real is also the register of the drive and jouissance. This seems to suggest that the psychoanalytic idea of trauma as the jouissance of the drive, or drive-jouissance, is not so far away from the mental health concept of trauma after all \u2013 except for one important difference. And this goes back to the question of the <em>source<\/em> of the trauma, which for the mental health discourse is still \u2018external\u2019, \u2018out there\u2019 in the world, in the Other.<\/p>\n<p>With regards to the psychoanalytic discourse of trauma, for want of a better term, things are far more complicated because although the Other does have a role to play in the constitution of trauma, this is subject to a complex process of unconscious ciphering and symbolic mediation. This is something I will be returning to in another article but for the time being I will conclude by arguing that in my view Ferenczi and his colleagues were onto something with their theory of the war neuroses all those years ago in Budapest but perhaps didn\u2019t fully understand what it was\u2026<\/p>\n<h4>Notes and references<\/h4>\n<ol>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-1\">S\u00e1ndor Ferenczi and others, <em>Psycho-Analysis and the War Neuroses<\/em> (Vienna: The International Psycho-Analytical Press, 1921). The book also included a paper written by Ernest Jones and which was originally read before the Royal Society of Medicine, Section of Psychiatry, in April 1918. <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-1\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-2\">Correia, S\u00edlvia, and Pedro Mu\u00f1oz, \u2018The Great War and the Fifth International Psychoanalytic Congress in Budapest: Psychoanalysis in the 1910s\u2019, <em>Historia Cr\u00edtica<\/em>, 84, 2022, 3\u201327 <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-2\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-3\">For example, in his Introduction Freud writes: \u201cThe war neuroses, in so far as they differ from the ordinary neuroses of peace time through particular peculiarities, are to be regarded as traumatic neuroses, whose existence has been rendered possible or promoted through an ego-conflict.\u201d (p.2) <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-3\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-4\">To quote Freud again: \u201c\u2026the opponents of psycho-analysis, whose repugnance to sexuality has shown itself to be stronger than their logic, have hastened to proclaim that investigation of the war neuroses has finally disproved this part of the psycho-analytical theory.\u201d (p.2). <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-4\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-5\">Sigmund Freud, \u2018Beyond the Pleasure Principle\u2019, in <em>The Standard Edition<\/em> (London: Hogarth Press, 1920g), XVIII, 3\u201364. <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-5\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-6\">Or in some cases, psychotic or narcissistic. <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-6\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-7\">Ferenczi et al, <em>Psycho-Analysis and the War Neuroses<\/em>, p.31. <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-7\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-8\">Ibid., p.23. <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-8\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<li id=\"post-5375-footnote-9\">Although Mu\u00f1oz and Correia acknowledge that the \u2018white terror\u2019 resulted in the emigration of many analysts (one of the principle reasons for the dismantling of the HPA) they still argue that the Congress had a more lasting legacy; for example in the establishment of free analysis clinics in Berlin, Vienna, London and Tegel. They also highlight the fact that representatives of the military authorities attended the Congress and agreed to open up psychoanalytic treatment stations for soldiers. However, it\u2019s important to note that with regards to the latter, this idea never had any real lasting traction. <a href=\"#post-5375-footnote-ref-9\">\u2191<\/a><\/li>\n<\/ol>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>In September 1918 a Symposium was held at the Fifth International Psycho-Analytical Congress in Budapest on the subject of the war neuroses. S\u00e1ndor Ferenczi, Karl Abraham and Ernst Simmel all presented papers on this topic, and Freud himself wrote the introduction to the proceedings of the Symposium which were published &hellip;<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_acf_changed":false,"inline_featured_image":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[19,20],"tags":[372,213,371],"class_list":["post-5375","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-trauma-post-topics","category-trauma-history-and-memory","tag-drive-jouissance","tag-ptsd-2","tag-war-neuroses"],"acf":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5375","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=5375"}],"version-history":[{"count":3,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5375\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":5387,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/5375\/revisions\/5387"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=5375"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=5375"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/therapeia.org.uk\/ttr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=5375"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}