Three types of trauma?
Three types of trauma?

Three types of trauma?

In my previous post I argued that there are two, very different, discourses of trauma. The first is what I labelled as the ‘mental health’ discourse, and the other I called the ‘psychoanalytic’ discourse. The ‘mental health’ discourse essentially regards trauma as related to specific events in a subject’s life, for example childhood sexual abuse, war, etc. Even if the individual is not (consciously) affected at the time of the occurrence of the ‘original’ event, at some point later (which could be years or even decades) they can start to experience a range of symptoms, for example, flashbacks, nightmares, panic attacks and a range of psychosomatic disorders. Nowadays, these symptoms are likely to be ‘diagnosed’ as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

The treatment for such symptoms often involves encouraging the subject to ‘work through’ the memories of such experiences and to try and make some kind of sense of them. This may well involve the construction of a trauma narrative, which gives the traumatic event (and the subject themselves) a history. Such a construction often takes place within the context of some form of talking therapy, which can range from cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) to various types of person-centred therapies and even certain variants of psychoanalytic therapies. The basic aim of all these therapies to help the subject assimilate the traumatic memories into their existing subjective ‘schemas’ or ‘worldviews’.

At this point, though, I think its important to point out that term ‘mental health discourse’ is referring to the way trauma is conceptualised and treated (and, I would argue, politicised). However, the subject matter of such a discourse, which for the sake of argument I will refer to as the ‘traumas of life’, could equally as well, in my view, be approached from another angle, and this is where the psychoanalytic discourse comes in.

The psychoanalytic discourse regards trauma as something constitutive or foundational to the human subject. Just to somewhat complicate things, there are two different ways to interpret this idea of ‘foundational’: one is that the human being is ‘traumatised’ by its entry into language; the other is that such traumatisation is not a ‘one-off’ event but something continuous in the life of the subject and is linked to the jouissance of the (death) drive. In many ways these two interpretations of ‘foundational’ complement one another: there is an initial traumatisation which ‘founds’ the subject, but then there is an ongoing traumatisation which is an effect of the drive. This initial traumatisation could, perhaps, also be described as an ‘inaugural trauma’, whereas the ongoing traumatisation could be described as the ‘trauma of the drive.’

So, what we have so far are two distinct discourses of trauma, and, it would seem, three ways to describe trauma, that is, the traumas of life, the inaugural trauma, and the trauma of the drive. Of course, just to complicate things even more, there is the question of how each discourse constructs its subject, that is, trauma, in the first place. Leaving this issue to one side for the time being, the question that immediately comes to my mind is how, if at all, these three ‘types’ of trauma relate to one another. And, more specifically, how do the traumas of life relate to the other two, ‘psychoanalytic’, types of trauma?

Why does this matter? To start with, it might be tempting to make a clear distinction between the traumas of life and the psychoanalytic types of trauma in order to demarcate what is the province of psychoanalysis and what is not; in other words, traumas of life are for psychotherapy, CBT and other ‘talking therapies’, whereas the inaugural trauma and the trauma of the drive are for psychoanalysis.

But in terms of clinical practice, this demarcation is surely misplaced; in my experience at least, no-one ever ‘presents’ with a desire for an analysis. Apart from anything else, they are unlikely to have a clear view in their own minds what an ‘analysis’ actually is. And even if they do have an initial idea (or fantasy) about what constitutes an analysis, then the chances are this will change as the work continues. Rather, they are far more likely to present with a particular problem, which may or not involve one or more traumas of life. With regards to someone ‘presenting’ with a specific complaint, for example, flashbacks, nightmares, panic attacks, then they may well be looking for a ‘quick fix’, that is, for the analyst to somehow ‘cure’ them of these symptoms. As time goes by the individual will either decide the analysis isn’t ‘working’ (because of a lack of ‘cure’), or they may decide to stick around to see what happens next.

However, this in itself does not address the question of any potential relationship between the traumas of life and the two psychoanalytic types of trauma. The fact that someone may be ‘presenting’ with a trauma of life does not mean it has anything to do with the inaugural trauma and/or the trauma of the drive. However, what if, for the sake of argument, the traumas of life are a manifestation of the trauma of the drive…?

 

While psychoanalytic theory conceptualises trauma, repetition, and the limits of the signifier, clinical work takes place in the singular encounter with one’s own symptom. If you are seeking a space to speak that lies outside directive or manualised therapies, I can offer psychoanalytic consultations online via Therapeia.  Please click here for further details.