The exhaustion of the signifier and the turn to topology
Why did Jacques Lacan, in the twilight of his teaching, find it necessary to abandon the elegance of structural linguistics for the seemingly arcane geometry of knots and links? One answer, which I have already touched upon in previous discussions of Lacan’s ‘Borromean turn’, is that the model of the signifier reached a point of narrative exhaustion when confronted with the irreducible nature of jouissance.1 If the unconscious is structured like a language, there remains nonetheless a residue that language cannot grasp, a traumatic kernel that resists the symbolic order and remains fundamentally opaque to the work of interpretation.2 This residue, which Lacan identified as the Real, required a new formalisation that could account for the way in which a subject is held together (or fails to be held together) outside the guarantees of the Other. The shift to topology was not a flight into abstraction but a rigorous attempt to provide a literal representation of psychic structure, where the knot is not a metaphor for the subject but is the structure itself.3
The transition from a clinic presided over by the Symbolic to one presided over by the Real marks the movement from the 1950s focus on the paternal metaphor to the 1970s focus on the Borromean link. Whereas the earlier Lacan emphasised the capacity of the Name-of-the-Father to anchor meaning and regulate the subject’s relation to desire,4 the later Lacan recognised that the Name-of-the-Father is merely one possible way of knotting the registers of experience. What is at stake here is the very viability of a psychoanalytic intervention that does not rely on the restoration of a traditional authority. If the Other does not ek-sist,5 or if the Other is barred and inconsistent, what is it that prevents the subject from descending into the chaos of psychosis? The answer lies in the topological properties of the Borromean link, where the three registers of the Real, the Symbolic, and the Imaginary (RSI) are held together in a way that respects their mutual autonomy while ensuring their functional interdependence.6
The Borromean logic of the three registers
As is well documented, the Borromean link (knot) consists of at least three rings so linked that if any one ring is cut, the others fall apart; no two rings are directly linked to one another, but the triad is maintained by the way they overlap and interweave. In this configuration, Lacan identifies the three fundamental registers of human subjectivity.7 The Imaginary involves the consistency of the body, the ego, and the domain of identifications; the Symbolic encompasses the signifier, the law, and the hole created by language; and the Real refers to that which resists symbolisation, the domain of traumatic jouissance and non-sense. Because these registers are fundamentally heterogeneous, their knotting is not a natural occurrence but a structural achievement that requires a specific orientation.
This suggests that subject is no longer a thinking substance in the Cartesian sense, but an effect of the knotting of these three autonomous consistencies. If we take the Borromean model seriously, we must acknowledge that there is no hierarchy among the registers; the Symbolic is no longer the ‘master’ of the Real or the Imaginary. Instead, the subject exists only at the intersection of these fields.8 However, as Lacan noted in Seminar XXIII, the three-ringed knot is often an idealisation. In clinical reality, the rings frequently stand apart, failing to interlock in a way that would prevent the unravelling of the psyche. This structural failure, which is the root of both neurosis and psychosis, necessitates the introduction of a fourth term: the sinthome.9
In his earlier work, Lacan described the Name-of-the-Father as the crucial signifier that anchors the subject’s world. In the topological period, this paternal function is reinterpreted as a specific form of the sinthome, a fourth ring that ties the other three together. The Oedipus complex is thus seen not as a universal truth but as a ‘pret-a-porter’ (ready-to-wear) solution to the problem of human existence, a way of knotting the Real, Symbolic, and Imaginary through the mediation of the phallic function.10 Why should this matter to the clinician? Because it implies that the failure of the father is not a catastrophe that must be cured, but a structural gap that can be addressed through other means of knotting.
Neurosis: the phallic knotting and its tensions
Neurosis, in the Lacanian orientation, is defined by the operation of repression (Verdrängung), which involves the subject’s refusal to recognise something that is nonetheless registered in the Symbolic order. Topologically, the neurotic subject is one whose knot is held together by the Name-of-the-Father, yet this knotting is characterised by a persistent tension and dissatisfaction. The neurotic symptom is a way of ‘making a circle with the unconscious,’ a repetitive formation that attempts to manage the jouissance that the Symbolic order has failed to fully civilise.
The hysteric is the subject who seeks to be the lack in the Other, ensuring that the Other’s desire remains unsatisfied so that it may continue to exist. In the Borromean clinic, this can be interpreted as a ‘rigid tension’ between the registers, where the subject uses the Symbolic to question the master and maintain their position as the object that causes the Other’s desire. The hysteric’s symptom is a message addressed to the Other, a call for a knowledge that the Other does not possess. This structural arrangement is stable, but it is a stability built on the constant frustration of the subject’s own desire. In this sense the hysteric’s suffering is the price they pay for keeping the Other alive.
The obsessional subject, by contrast, uses the Symbolic to encircle and isolate the Real, creating elaborate rituals and mental loops that aim to postpone the encounter with the Other’s desire. Topologically, the obsessional’s knot is one where the Symbolic and Imaginary registers are used to create a ‘dead zone’ around the Real of jouissance. The obsessional works to ensure that nothing happens, that the world remains consistent and predictable, even if this consistency is purchased at the cost of a profound internal paralysis. The symptom in obsession is not so much a call to the Other as it is a wall built against it.
Psychosis and the catastrophe of unknotting
The defining mechanism of psychosis is foreclosure (Verwerfung), the radical rejection of the Name-of-the-Father from the Symbolic register. When this primary signifier is absent, the Symbolic order cannot perform its function of knotting the other registers, and the three rings fall apart. This unknotting results in the catastrophic experience of psychosis, where the Real of the body and the Real of language invade the subject’s world without the mediation of the Imaginary or the Symbolic.
One of the most striking clinical manifestations of this unknotting is the slippage of the Imaginary register. Without the anchor of the Symbolic, the subject’s sense of bodily consistency begins to fail. This is precisely what Lacan identified in the case of James Joyce, who recounted an experience of being whipped at school and feeling as if his body were a husk being peeled away. This ‘husk-like’ existence is a direct consequence of the Imaginary ring failing to interlock with the Real and the Symbolic. The subject is no longer ‘clothed’ by their image, but is exposed to the raw intensities of a jouissance that has no place in the world.
If the knot has unravelled, how does the psychotic subject survive? The answer is through the construction of a delusional metaphor, an attempt to ‘re-knot’ the registers through a singular creation. The delusion is not a symptom of the illness but a form of ‘repair,’ a way of localising jouissance and instituting a supplementation where the Name-of-the-Father is missing. In paranoia, this re-knotting often takes the form of a suture, where the subject creates a consistent, if terrifying, Symbolic world that accounts for the intrusion of the Real. The delusional system provides a new consistency, a way for the subject to ‘hold together’ in the face of the void.
The rigid binary between neurosis and psychosis that dominated the early Lacanian clinic was challenged by Jacques-Alain Miller’s introduction of the category of ‘Ordinary Psychosis’. This is not a new structure but a clinical designation for subjects who have a psychotic structure (foreclosure of the Name-of-the-Father) but who have found a way to maintain a ‘Borromean’ stability without a full-blown clinical breakdown. These subjects do not present with the extraordinary phenomena of classical psychosis, such as voices or grandiose delusions; instead, they display ‘discrete signs’ of a fragile stabilisation.
In the clinic of ordinary psychosis, the analyst must attend to subtle disturbances in the subject’s relation to language, the body, and the social link. These subjects often rely on ‘semblants’—rigid social roles, conformist identifications, or professional identities—that function as a local sinthome. A man might be entirely ‘ordinary’ as long as he is at his desk, but if he is forced into a situation where he must speak in his own name, the knot may begin to unravel. The clinical task here is one of ‘stitching’ and ‘gluing,’ supporting the subject’s existing compensations rather than attempting to dismantle them through interpretation.
Why is this category so vital for contemporary practice? Because it reminds us that ‘all the world is mad,’ in the sense that everyone’s sense of reality is a construction. The difference between the ordinary psychotic and the neurotic is not an essence but a different mode of knotting. If we assume that every subject is a neurotic in search of a lost meaning, we risk triggering a catastrophe in those for whom the Symbolic order is already a fragile artifice.
Perversion: the fetishistic suture and the instrument of jouissance
Perversion (Verleugnung or disavowal) represents a structural arrangement where the subject recognises the lack in the Other but acts as if the phallus nonetheless exists. Topologically, the pervert is the one who sustains the knot through a compensatory identification with the object, often a fetish. The fetish functions like a sinthome, a rigid formation that ties the registers together by bypassing the hole in the Symbolic. In perversion, the Real and the Imaginary are frequently knotted together in a way that excludes the Symbolic’s regulating function. The perverse ritual is a ‘suture’ that closes the gap of castration, allowing the subject to inhabit a world where jouissance is possible and guaranteed. Lacan used the term père-version (a ‘version towards the father’) to describe how the pervert makes himself the instrument of the Other’s jouissance to ensure that the Other is not lacking. Unlike the neurotic, who is divided by his desire, the pervert is ‘whole,’ identified with the very object that causes the Other’s enjoyment.
Ironically, the pervert is often the most ‘stable’ of subjects, provided their ritual remains intact. The clinical difficulty arises when the fetishist solution fails, or when the subject is forced to confront the Real that their ritual was designed to clothe. In the Borromean clinic, perversion is seen as a ‘perfect’ but brittle solution to the failure of the Other; a way of being ‘at home’ in the Real at the cost of a radical alienation from the Symbolic.
Seminar XXIII: the sinthome and the case of James Joyce
Lacan’s engagement with James Joyce in Seminar XXIII marks the culmination of his late teaching and the final evolution of the concept of the symptom. Lacan argued that Joyce was structurally psychotic, insofar that the Name-of-the-Father had failed to knot his registers; but he avoided a clinical breakdown through his ‘artifice’. Joyce’s writing functioned as his sinthome, a fourth ring that artificially tied the Symbolic, Imaginary, and Real together. In Joyce’s case the sinthome took the form of his ego, which was not the Imaginary ego of common experience but a ‘literary’ ego constructed through his work. By deconstructing language through creating Finnegans Wake, Joyce reached the level of lalangue, the Real of language before it is shaped into meaning. His enigmatic writing did not communicate a message to the Other; it was a vehicle of jouissance that allowed him to ‘make a name for himself’ and repair the deficit in his structural knotting.
This leads to a radical conclusion for clinical practice: the goal of analysis is not to ‘cure’ the subject by removing their symptom, but to help them ‘identify with the sinthome’. If the symptom is a source of suffering, the sinthome is a source of consistency and satisfaction; it is what ‘allows the subject to hold together’. The Joyce case demonstrates that one can get by without the Name-of-the-Father, provided one knows how to ‘make use of’ a singular artifice.
Clinical practice in the Real: the analyst as sinthome
What is it to practice psychoanalysis in the Borromean clinic? It means that the analyst must move beyond the ‘ideology’ of the signifier and attend to the structural integrity of the subject’s knot. Interpretation is no longer just about uncovering repressed truth; it is an act of ‘cutting,’ ‘gluing,’ or ‘tying’ the rings of experience. If the analyst’s words do not reach the Real of the subject’s jouissance, then the analysis is merely a play of shadows. In his later teaching, Lacan argued that the analyst himself may function as a sinthome for the analysand. By occupying the position of the Object a (the non-symbolised remainder of the Real) the analyst provides a temporary ‘fourth ring’ that allows the analysand to explore their structure without the risk of an unravelling. This is particularly critical in the treatment of ordinary psychosis and ‘unclassifiable’ cases, where the analyst must be a ‘supplement’ to a failing Symbolic order.
The end of analysis, therefore, is not the discovery of a final meaning, but the subject’s arrival at a ‘know-how’ with their own jouissance. The analysand must learn to ‘savour’ their sinthome, to recognize the singular logic that gives their life consistency in a world where the Other is absent. Analysis ends when the subject can testify to the fact that they are ‘knotted’ in a way that works for them, even if that knotting is unconventional or ‘heretical’.
The ethical imperative of the knot
Why does it matter if we think of the subject as a knot or as a narrative? One answer is that the narrative model always risks collapsing into ’empathy’ or ‘understanding,’ which are merely Imaginary misrecognitions that cover over the Real of the subject’s structure. The topological model, by contrast, forces us to confront the structural dynamics of the psyche; the ways in which jouissance is ‘wedged’ between the registers. The Borromean clinic is a clinic of links and limits, where the analyst is responsible for helping the subject find the boundaries of their own existence. This is a rigorous and unsentimental practice that does not seek to ‘heal’ the subject but to help them inhabit their own madness with a certain grace.
In the contemporary era, where traditional Symbolic structures are increasingly in decline, the Borromean knot provides an indispensable tool for understanding the myriad ways in which subjects attempt to ‘hold together’. Whether through the paternal sinthome of neurosis, the delusional metaphor of psychosis, or the fetishist suture of perversion, every subject is an artist of their own survival. The role of psychoanalysis is to witness and support these singular solutions, ensuring that the subject can continue to exist in the gap between the Symbolic hole and the Real of jouissance.
Notes and references
- Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XX: Encore, On Feminine Sexuality, the Limits of Love and Knowledge, ed. Jacques-Alain Miller, trans. Bruce Fink (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1998), 101–105.↩︎
- Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XI: The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psychoanalysis, ed. Jacques-Alain Miller, trans. Alan Sheridan (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1981), 203–215.↩︎
- Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XXIII: The Sinthome, ed. Jacques-Alain Miller, trans. A. R. Price (Cambridge: Polity Press, 2016), 18–25↩︎
- Jacques Lacan, ‘On a Question Prior to Any Possible Treatment of Psychosis’, in Écrits: The First Complete Edition in English, trans. Bruce Fink (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 2006), 445–488↩︎
- The spelling ‘ek-sist’ is a reminder that both Lacan and Miller were drawing upon Heidegger’s term ek-sistenz, to stand out, although were using in a different context to that of Heidegger.↩︎
- Jean-Michel Rabaté, Jacques Lacan, (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2001), 134–140.↩︎
- Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XX: Encore, 120–125.↩︎
- Luke Thurston, James Joyce and the Problem of Psychoanalysis, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004), 172–178.↩︎
- Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XXIII: The Sinthome, 80–95.↩︎
- Jacques-Alain Miller, ‘The Sinthome, a New Way of Writing the Symptom,’ The Lacanian Review 2, no. 1 (2016): 34–42.↩︎
The formalisation of the Borromean knots provides the scaffolding for a contemporary clinic of the Real. To explore further entries on the ‘very late Lacan’ and the status of the subject, please visit The Borromean Clinic Hub.
Last updated: May 6, 2026
