In lesson five of Seminar XI, following his remarks regarding the automaton as the network of signifiers and the Real as that which is ‘beyond’ the automaton, Lacan makes the following statement:
The function of the tuché, of the real as encounter—the encounter in so far as it may be missed, in so far as it is essentially the missed encounter—first presented itself in the history of psycho-analysis in a form that was in itself already enough to arouse our attention, that of the trauma.[1]
Is Lacan arguing here that trauma is a missed encounter with the Real? Does it mean that, in a state of trauma, the subject somehow ‘side steps’ the Real? But this is not what Lacan appears to be saying in his seminar. In fact, in lesson five, and especially in his analysis of Freud’s ‘burning child’ dream, it is clear that he is arguing that trauma is an encounter with the Real. Furthermore, Jacques-Alain Miller, in his presentation Psychoanalysis, its place among the sciences, states that: ‘This real of Lacan’s, which cannot be said but about which one must speak, is what Freud called ‘trauma’. Lacan’s real is always traumatic. It is a hole in discourse.’[2]
And yet, I would argue, in one sense Lacan is right: in ‘normal’ life and, in fact, much of the time in analysis, the subject is forever having a missed encounter with the Real. And one reason for this concerns the nature of the transference, which in Seminar XI Lacan formulates in terms of the subject-supposed-to-know. More specifically, he argues that transference to the subject-supposed-to-know is the response of the subject’s encounter with trauma:
One may go so far as to believe that the opacity of the trauma—as it was then maintained in its initial function by Freud’s thought, that is to say, in my terms, its resistance to signification—is then specifically held responsible for the limits of remembering. And, after all, it is hardly surprising, given my own theorization, that I should see this as a highly significant moment in the transfer of powers from the subject to the Other, what I call the capital Other (le grand Autre), the locus of speech and, potentially, the locus of truth.[3]
Lacan argues that the Other, the subject-supposed-to-know, is already present in the opening of the unconscious, ‘however fleeting it may be’. Essentially, the transference is ‘the means by which the communication of the unconscious is interrupted’.[4] Pierre-Gilles Guéguen, in his paper Paradoxes of the Births of Transference, reinforces Lacan’s argument that transference occurs at the very moment of the encounter of the subject with the Real, with the trauma. As Guéguen explains:
Lacan’s expression “closing of the unconscious” in this context designates the fact that in transference the subject gives meaning back to what was disturbed. The subject forgets that he is but the effect of the signifying chain, that he is only its remainder, re-woven with the Symbolic and the Imaginary that for an instant becomes undone. The clinic of trauma gives us the most striking example of this.[5]
Guéguen cites the example of Freud’s text on the Acropolis where he experienced a momentary sense of depersonalisation. He ‘resolves’ this loss of meaning by ‘spinning the story of the rivalry with his father and his guilt at having socially “surpassed” him.’[6] In other words, the intervention of the Other is enough to bring Freud back to ‘reality’, that is, the Symbolic-Imaginary matrix. In this sense the encounter with the Real is not so much missed as avoided. The trauma of the Real is too much for the subject to bear so he or she ‘transfers’ to the Other.
And yet, somewhat paradoxically, Lacan also argues in Seminar XI that “…the transference is the enactment of the unconscious.”[7] Furthermore, such an unconscious is consubstantial with sexuality. In another paper Guéguen goes onto point out that in Seminar XI “…Lacan announces that while transference closes up the unconscious, repetition – somewhat surprisingly – allows for its opening.”[8] This makes it clear that, for Lacan at least, transference should not be seen as a ‘repetition’ in the analytic setting of the subject’s earlier relationships, for example with his or her parents. Instead, as Guéguen explains, Lacan “…focuses the attention on the type of repetition that opens up to the unconscious as trauma because it unceasingly indicates how the subject defends himself from the real, how he avoids it.”[9] And the subject avoids the Real through…the transference. So what we have here is strange type of dynamic (or dialectic) involving the perpetual ‘missing’ of the subject’s encounter with the Real. In other words, at the moment of the subject’s encounter with the Real, there is a move (a ‘transfer’) to the Symbolic.
And in many ways such a paradoxical encounter-missed encounter encapsulates the work of analysis itself, insofar as every analysis is an encounter with the Real that fails. Or, rather, an encounter that fails to the extent that the analysis can only continue on the basis of such a failure; because ‘success’ would mean an irruption of the Real into the analytic session, which would most likely result in at least a temporary suspension of the analysis. One example of such an irruption would be when the subject experiences a psychotic break during the analysis and ends up being hospitalised. And perhaps this is the real challenge for the analyst: to handle the transference in such a way that subject encounters the Real without actually encountering it…too much.
References
- Jacques Lacan, The Four Fundamental Concepts of Psycho-Analysis (London: Penguin, 1979), 55 (hereafter Seminar XI).. ↑
- Jacques-Alain Miller, ‘Psychoanalysis, Its Place among the Sciences’, Psychoanalytical Notebooks, 27, 2013, 17. ↑
- Lacan, Seminar XI, 129. ↑
- Ibid., 130. ↑
- Pierre-Gilles Guéguen, “Paradoxes of the Births of Transference,” Psychoanalytical Notebooks, no. 17 (March 2008): 41–45. ↑
- Ibid., 43. ↑
- Lacan, Seminar XI, 146. ↑
- Pierre-Gilles Gueguen, “Transference: A Paradoxical Concept,” LC Express 2, no. 12 (December 2014), 4. ↑
- Ibid., 5. ↑
Last updated: October 30, 2024