Trauma, language and the Real limit of AI
Trauma, language and the Real limit of AI

Trauma, language and the Real limit of AI

The desert of the real

Introduction: the dream of total meaning

The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) and especially large language models (LLMs) has raised the possibility (or spectre) of what might best be described as a ‘totalisation’ of knowledge and meaning. In other words, we are now moving towards a position whereby the sum of all human (and, increasingly, non-human or synthetic) knowledge will reside in vast banks of digital memory – something the Encyclopédistes of the eighteenth century could only dream of. Of course, LLMs offer far more than simply being the latest incarnation of the subject-supposed-to-know;[1] they can also be your best friend, your therapist, your lover, your researcher, and so much more. However, I would argue that it is only by virtue of being this (digital) Other, this (supposed) guarantor and fulfilment of all Knowledge and Truth, that they can fulfil any of these other functions.

Furthermore, AI has found the perfect vehicle for its propagation in the form of what might be best described as ‘convergent media’, that is, the convergence between social and traditional media. Even prior to the appearance of LLMs social media was already redefining the fabric of the social and the political, and in many ways social media is the new social and political reality. Of course, both the social and the political have always been mediated in one form or another; the idea of a golden age of ‘real’ human relations is a myth. The very fact that we are speaking (and writing) beings is testimony to our Fall into language and, consequently, the loss of a ‘direct connection’ with one another. However, I would argue that social media has essentially taken this to another level. And the emergence of AI and LLMs, as I argue later in this text, marks a move to what I describe as a global saturation of knowledge and meaning.

There is, however, an absolute, ontological limit to meaning because in any discourse something always escapes signification. This something is a ‘piece of the Real’, the object a, which in his later work Lacan will redefine as surplus jouissance. This means there can never be a ‘totalisation’ of meaning, whether this is driven by human or artificial intelligence. Thus, the dream of Encyclopédistes (to say nothing of the transhumanists) for absolute and total knowledge is doomed to failure. Instead, what emerges in the midst of meaning is the Real, in the form of trauma. A Real that is inherent in language itself rather than something ‘external’ to language and meaning. This essentially means that any ‘totalisation’ of meaning leads, in fact, to a ‘totalisation’ of trauma, a complete breakdown of meaning. In this article I will discuss how this occurs within the context of AI and the globalised mediascape.

The Real as a function of language

The Lacanian Real is often presented as being ‘outside’ of language, something akin to Kant’s noumena, the thing-in-itself. One of the unfortunate consequences of this approach, in my view, is that it has tended to reinforce a form of linguistic essentialism in much Lacanian theory which privileges language and meaning over any attempts to establish a material base for language itself. In this view, which was very much the driving force of post-structuralism and so-called ‘French Theory’, language is taken as a ‘given’, it is just ‘there’. And, ironically, such linguistic essentialism is used to critique other forms of essentialism, and especially those that posit a more materialist ontology.

One of the difficulties with the ‘outside of language’ approach to the Real is that it raises an age-old philosophical problem: how does one represent, think about, that which is beyond representation? One way round this difficulty is to argue that the Real is only known by its effects; and, more specifically, by its retroactive effects. In other words, the Real is essentially a theoretical device to explain certain empirical phenomena. Now, this way of conceptualising that which is beyond conceptualisation is very different from simply stating that the Real is ‘beyond language’ or is ‘extra-discursive’. If the Real is a theoretical invention then it is clearly discursive and therefore ‘within’ language. However, if the Real is a discursive ‘device’ to explain certain phenomena then where does this leave the ‘beyond language’ argument? In other words, if the idea of a ‘beyond language’ is itself a linguistic construction then doesn’t this simply reinforce the case for linguistic essentialism? Perhaps a better way to look at this is to argue that the so-called ‘limit’ of language is, in fact, the limit of meaning; or, even more precisely, especially within the context of AI, the limit of human comprehension.

The idea of retroactivity is key in understanding how the Real is a function of language itself. It is something that Lacan refers to in various parts of his teaching, for example in his development of the Graph of Desire. However, it features most prominently in the form of Freud’s theory of Nachträglichkeit, a topic that I have written about extensively elsewhere on this site and in my book on traumatic neurosis. [2] Put very briefly, Nachträglichkeit is the term used to describe how the history of the human subject is a series of retranscriptions (Freud’s term) or retranslations (Laplanche’s term). Each retranscription occurs at a moment of crisis of the life of the subject and each retranscription is an attempt to ‘resolve’ the crisis. However, each attempt to rewrite the subject’s history ultimately fails because there is something always left unwritten, untranscribed. And this something is something of the Real, something of the trauma.

One of the misunderstandings about the concept of Nachträglichkeit, which is not helped by James Strachey’s mistranslation of the term as ‘deferred action’, is that it represents a ‘delayed’ trauma. In other words, an ‘original’ traumatic event occurs in the subject’s life, often in their early childhood, which is then ‘forgotten’ (repressed), sometimes for many years or even decades. At a later point in the subject’s history another event occurs which ‘triggers’ the memory of the ‘original’ trauma. As indicated above, there can actually be a series of ‘triggers’, each one resulting in an attempt by the subject to ‘accommodate’ the memory of the ‘original’ trauma into their history. But this is not what Freud meant by Nachträglichkeit; rather the trauma occurs at the time of the retranscription. Certainly, the retranscription is an attempt to ‘write’ the trauma into the subject’s existing history; a ‘writing’ that results in a rewriting of the subject’s entire life story. However, what is being (or attempting to be) written) into the subject’s history is not the memory of an ‘original’ traumatic event; rather, it is an attempt to ‘write’ an irruption of the Real into the subject’s ‘reality’.

The key point about Nachträglichkeit is that it shows that the Real (trauma) is present within language itself and that something of the Real always escapes meaning. This ‘something of the Real’ is what Lacan would initially define as the object a and in his later teachings as surplus jouissance. This surplus jouissance is the remainder (and a reminder) of a ‘lost’ jouissance, an Other jouissance,[3] that forever eludes the subject.

In Seminar XVII Lacan argues that the signifier is an apparatus of jouissance. However, there is a further key part of Lacan’s argument, and this is that in its endless repetition, jouissance is running down, disappearing, which he refers to as its entropy. At the same time, though, something appears in place of this ‘disappeared’ or ‘lost’ jouissance, the object a:

What becomes evident…is, as we were saying just before, that there is a loss of jouissance. And it is in the place of this loss introduced by repetition that we see the function of the lost object emerge, of what I am calling the a. What does this impose on us? If not this formula that at the most elementary level, that of the imposition of the unary trait, knowledge at work produces, let’s say, an entropy.[4]

This ‘lost object’, the object a, is a ‘stand-in’ for the ‘actual jouissance’ of the subject, and in the same seminar is described by Lacan as surplus jouissance. However, in developing his concept of surplus jouissance Lacan also discounts his previous argument (in Seminar VII) that jouissance is a transgression, something forbidden; on the contrary, argues Lacan:

We are not dealing with a transgression, an irruption into some forbidden field through the wearing away of vital regulatory apparatuses (the pleasure principle). In fact, it is only through this effect of entropy, through this wasting, that jouissance acquires a status and shows itself. This is why I initially introduced it by the term “Mehrlust,” surplus jouissance…Only the dimension of entropy gives body to the fact that there is surplus jouissance there to be recovered.[5]

In other words, jouissance is an effect of the repetition of the signifier; a repetition that is ‘powered’ by the circuit of the drive. However, this is a jouissance that is perpetually ‘decaying’, so to speak, like the radioactive decay of certain particles. The key point about surplus jouissance is that its production is directly correlated with the production of meaning. In other words the more meaning that is generated within a discourse the more surplus jouissance will appear. This means that there is no way to ‘write out’ surplus jouissance through the production of ever-more elaborate narratives.

Surplus jouissance and trauma

The reason I have spent time discussing the nature of language in relation to surplus jouissance is in order to show how meaning produces (surplus) jouissance rather than being a way to ‘treat’ jouissance, that is, to decipher jouissance, which is often how it viewed in psychoanalytic theory and treatment. Or to be more precise, there is always a limit to the extent that meaning can decipher jouissance because the process of producing meaning also produces a surplus of jouissance. But the critical point here is that surplus jouissance is the site of trauma. In other words, meaning produces trauma as much as it ‘alleviates’ it. And as we shall see, this has profound implications when it comes to the idea of a globalised mediascape driven by AI.

The idea of trauma emanating from surplus jouissance, so to speak, may sound rather peculiar. After all, isn’t trauma something that ‘happens’ to people; something that emanates from the ‘external’ world in the form of ‘traumatic events’? This is certainly the popular view of trauma and one which provides the basis for what might be best described as the ‘PTSD paradigm’. It also appears to be one that Freud himself subscribes to. In Beyond the Pleasure Principle he writes:

We describe as ‘traumatic’ any excitations from outside which are powerful enough to break through the protective shield. It seems to me that the concept of trauma necessarily implies a connection of this kind with a breach in an otherwise efficacious barrier against stimuli. Such an event as an external trauma is bound to provoke a disturbance on a large scale in the functioning of the organism’s energy and to set in motion every possible defensive measure. At the same time, the pleasure principle is for the moment put out of action.[6]

A closer look at this quote, however, reveals that there is more to Freud’s argument than simply positing an ‘external’ cause for trauma; or rather, it is by no means clear what he means by ‘external’ in this context. Bearing in mind that in this paper Freud is developing his concept of the death drive it seems reasonable to suppose that such a drive might play a major role in the constitution of trauma. And in his later paper, Inhibitions, Symptoms and Anxiety, it is clearer that trauma is linked to the drive: “The danger is known and real but the anxiety in regard to it is over-great, greater than seems proper to us. It is this surplus of anxiety which betrays the presence of a neurotic element. Such cases, however, introduce no new principle; for analysis shows that to the known real danger an unknown instinctual one is attached.”[7] What Freud is arguing here is that although there may be an event occurring in the external world, this event is not ‘traumatic’ in itself. It is only when it becomes linked to the operation of the drive (which Strachey translates as ‘instinct’) that the traumatisation occurs, which in Freud’s parlance is the (excess) excitation of the psychical apparatus.

However, the key point here is that it is the action of the drive which ‘produces’ trauma, not the ‘imposition’ of the event on the subject. In other words, drive-jouissance (trauma) is produced by the circulation of the drive around the object a (surplus jouissance) rather than being the effect of an external event upon the subject. But even here things are a bit more complicated. Recalling my discussion in the previous section regarding the nature of surplus jouissance, Lacan argued in Seminar XVII that this is an effect of the circulation of the drive itself; however, if this is the case then how can the drive be described as circulating around the very thing it produces? The answer is that the object a, surplus jouissance, is a retroactive effect of the drive’s circulation.

The concept of drive-jouissance is something I explore at length in my book on traumatic neurosis, and the core of my argument is that traumatic neurosis, the precursor to today’s PTSD, is an effect of the jouissance of the drive, which in turn represents an irruption of the Real into the subject’s Symbolic-Imaginary. And although the term drive-jouissance does not appear to be currently in wide use in the Lacanian literature it does get a mention in Jean-Louis Gault’s paper on the symptom, where he argues that a neurotic “…is a subject who has found a solution to defend himself against the real. This solution relies on the Name-of-the-Father and the fundamental identification that goes with it.” A defence against the Real is essentially a defence against trauma and, according to Gault “…always involves a repression of drive-jouissance.” The problem here, however, is that such a solution always fails and the subject is “…contaminated by the return of drive-jouissance.” [8]

And Jacques-Alain Miller references the idea in his paper on feminine jouissance:

Lacan’s last teaching keeps the reference to castration while disjoining it from prohibition. He tries to ensure that castration is nothing more than logical negation, nothing more than the fact of not being able to hold all the signifiers together. Also at this juncture of his teaching—which I say is prophetic for us— he prompts the analytical practice to focus on jouissance as an event of the body, that is to say, escaping the dialectics of prohibition/permission.

This positioning goes as far as to question what he called the objet a. Lacan had forged the notion from the object that was called pregenital by isolating in the analytic experience a so-called drive jouissance, which is external to phallic jouissance. We had then a hunch of a jouissance outside the signifier, but we could only isolate it in relation to the phallus…If he [Lacan] had sometimes shown that this drive jouissance was complementary or additional to castration, in all cases, the objet a prospered away from the phallus.[9]

What Miller is arguing here is to reiterate Lacan’s argument in Seminar XX that there is a jouissance that is beyond the phallus; an Other jouissance of which the object a (surplus jouissance) is the remainder/reminder of.

The saturation of the global media landscape

What, though, has any of this to do with AI and the globalisation of trauma? The key thing to remember here is that when it comes to the circulation of the drive and the retroactive construction of the object a (surplus jouissance) the ‘scope’, so to speak, of the drive is not restricted to the human body. Although the idea of the partial drives and partial objects that are restricted to certain area of the body is prevalent in Freud’s work and in the teachings of the ‘classical’ Lacan, in his later teaching and his introduction of the concept of surplus jouissance, the ‘scope’ of the drive becomes expanded beyond the body.

According to Miller: “We see our cultural world inhabited by substitutes for jouissance, which are little nothings. These are crumbs of jouissance which give a particular style to our way of life and our way of enjoying.” [10] What Miller is getting at here is that although previously Lacan (following Freud) was arguing that the objects of the drive were all ‘natural’, that is, the erogenous zones of the body, and therefore the object a was related to the ‘lost’ jouissance associated with each of these zones, with the advent of the concept of surplus jouissance this effectively generalises the idea of jouissance; in other words, anything, any object in world, can be the source of the ‘lost’ jouissance.

And one way to think of how the drive ‘searches’ the cultural landscape for such ‘crumbs of jouissance’ is to introduce the concept of drive-scraping. As I discuss in a previous article on this topic this is a term I have borrowed from the world of computing and the concept of web scraping. Put very briefly, this is the automated process of extracting data from websites. It involves using software or scripts to access web pages, parse their content (typically HTML), and retrieve specific information such as text, images, or links. Businesses, researchers, and developers use web scraping to gather data for market analysis, academic studies, price monitoring, and so on.[11]

The crux of my argument is that just as robots ‘scrape’ the web for ever more data, so does the drive ‘scrape’ the cultural landscape for ever more surplus jouissance. And it is worth noting, of course, that the Internet and the World Wide Web are very much part of this cultural landscape and provide the source of a great deal of Miller’s ‘crumbs of jouissance’. Furthermore, the analogy between drive and web scraping may be even more apt when we remember that in Seminar II Lacan’s argument regarding the mechanism of language and its relation to the drive drew heavily upon his interest in cybernetics which provides the foundations for modern computing and artificial intelligence (AI). This is something John Johnston discusses in some depth in his study of cybernetics, AI and artificial life.[12] Just as the analogy of web scraping seems to fit perfectly with the way the drive operates, so does the eternal circuit of the drive provide the perfect analogy for how LLMs operate as they scrape the web more and more content.

In essence we can think of the cultural world as constituting multiple sites of surplus jouissance, which in turn constitute multiple sites of trauma. And it’s at this point that AI and what I describe as ‘convergent media’ enter the picture. Although the concept of media convergence is not new, the advent of AI and LLMs has, in my opinion, given an added impetus to the concept. Essentially it is the idea that different forms of media, communication technologies and content delivery have converged into a unified system.[13] One example is the convergence of ‘traditional’ or ‘legacy’ media with social media where each form of media ‘borrows’ from the other. And the advent of satellite and internet technology means there is now a truly globalised mediascape operating 24/7.

But the critical point is not so much the globalisation of such media, which has been developing over a number of decades, but the fact that this new, convergent mediascape is now the new social and political reality. Again, in one sense this is not an especially new idea; in fact, it is very much part of Jean Baudriallard’s thesis of hyperreality and the simulacra.[14] In other words, the idea that representation has now been replaced by simulation. According to Baudrillard, there was a time when the sign referred to something beyond itself (the referent) which mean it represented reality; now, following Saussure, the sign simply refers to other signs which means the ‘referent’ disappears along with what Baudrillard calls ‘the real’ (which equates with ‘reality’ not the Lacanian Real) and all we are left with is a copy with no original; that is, a simulation or what Baudrillard refers to as ‘the hyperreal’.[15] And the key point here is that social and political life is now itself a simulation. To a certain extent this was already the case even prior to the advent of social media and the Internet: to what extent were the ‘events’ of 1968, for example, a media construction; or even (to use one of Baudrillard’s own examples) the Vietnam War itself that was raging at the same time?

The evolution of social media and the Internet has accelerated the move to hyperreality beyond anything Baudrillard could ever have dreamed of. And the emergence of AI and LLMs has, I would argue, taken this process to its logical conclusion. Our social and political life is essentially one massive, globalised simulacrum where concepts of ‘truth, ‘reality’ and meaning itself have been rendered meaningless. ‘Reality’ now effectively resides in the binary encoding of bank upon bank of sprawling AI databases and large language models. It is interesting to note, perhaps, that even in the 1970s and 1980s Baudrillard could see what was coming, particularly with regards to idea of ‘truth’ and ‘meaning’. Consider, for example, this passage from Simulacra and Simulation:

We live in a world where there is more and more information, and less and less meaning…there is a rigorous and necessary correlation between the two [information and meaning], to the extent that information is directly destructive of meaning and signification, or that it neutralizes them. The loss of meaning is directly linked to the dissolving, dissuasive action of information, the media, and the mass media.[16]

To this last sentence we could now add the Internet, social media and artificial intelligence. AI, especially in the form of LLMs, has the capacity to create and disseminate practically an infinite amount of information (content) across the new, convergent mediascape. But in doing so it renders the whole idea of meaning meaningless. And this is not simply because of the sheer volume of content, which makes it increasingly difficult to sift through it and decide what has value (especially ‘truth value’) and what doesn’t. The real problem is that there is no longer any ‘external’ reference point by which to make such a (truth) valuation in the first place. The hyperreal mediascape is folded in upon itself and there is literally no Other of the Other to guarantee the ‘truth’ of anything.

In Lacanian terms we might describe this as the universalisation of the One-all-alone or what Miller calls jouissance One. In order to develop this concept he begins by citing Lacan’s remark in Seminar XX: “Isn’t that precisely what psychoanalytic experience presupposes? – the substance of the body, on the condition that it is defined only as that which enjoys itself (se jouit).”[17] Miller goes onto argue that:

This starting point [of Lacan’s] implies a disjunction between jouissance and the Other. This point of departure which privileges jouissance is by itself enough to establish the non-rapport between jouissance and Other. Here ‘disjunction’ means ‘non-rapport’. This makes the Other of the Other appear in the form of the One. Around this time, Lacan had come to stress the One as the true Other of the Other.[18]

Along with the universalisation of jouissance One we have, as I argued earlier, the universalisation of surplus jouissance across the globalised mediascape (the new social and political ‘reality’). And it is within this globalised mediascape that millions (or rather, billions) of atomised Ones-all-alone are all desperately searching for ‘crumbs of (surplus) jouissance’. This is a landscape that is devoid of all meaning but full of (surplus) enjoyment, which effectively renders it a traumascape.[19] In other words it is a (hyperreal) landscape with infinite content but no meaning.

Conclusion: the Real limit of AI

So it would seem that we are now all trapped within the global simulacrum, which is saturated with content but completely devoid of meaning. It would appear that AI, as the driving force for convergent media, has finally realised Baudrillard’s idea of hyperreality; the map, the simulacra, has truly replaced the territory. And yet….perhaps this ‘totalisation’ of non-meaning marks the total undermining of AI itself. Or, rather, the undermining of the hyperreality that is made possible by AI. As I argued earlier, the saturation of content represents the saturation of the globalised mediascape with surplus jouissance, which in turn represents the saturation of such a mediascape with sites of trauma. This is because surplus jouissance (the object a in Lacan’s earlier teaching) represents ‘pieces of the Real’.

At this point it is critical to note the difference between the Lacanian Real and the Baudrillardian real. When Baudrillard famously refers to the ‘desert of the real’ in Simulacra and Simulation (a term immortalised in the film The Matrix) he is not referring to the Lacanian Real but, rather, to what we might best describe as ‘objective reality’. And although it is tempting to read this as another way to describe a world ‘outside’ or ‘beyond’ language and, therefore, simply another way to describe the Lacanian Real, this would be a serious error. As I argued earlier, the Real is not ‘outside’ or ‘beyond’ language, but rather a function of language itself. Furthermore, the Real is essentially a theoretical construct to explain real effects, notably the disruptions of language and the Symbolic-Imaginary order.

It is also worth pointing out that hyperreality itself has to have a material, ‘real’ base; that is, the technological infrastructure that makes the simulacra function in the first place. This seems to be something completely lost with most ‘post-modernists’ and ‘post-structuralists’. AI itself relies of a material base; one which uses a great deal of energy and computer firepower. And whenever someone bemoans the loss of ‘reality’ to the simulacra they rely on real technology to do so, that is, by using their computer, smartphone, etc. Having said that, it is also the case that once one becomes immersed in hyperreality, for example, in the world of social media, it becomes very easy to forget that this is underpinned by a ‘real’, material base. Hyperreality, like Baudrillard’s writing itself,[20] is totally seductive; it draws one into another world. But such a world is a mirage; a mirage in the desert of the real. The savage irony, though, is that such a desert of the real can only be reached through an irruption of the Real, that is, through trauma. In other words, the only way to shatter the illusion created by hyperreality is through trauma; a price most people, I suspect, are not prepared to pay.

However, there is an even more savage irony to this: it may be that we have no choice regarding paying such a price. In fact, this is core of my whole argument in this text: AI marks the final realisation of hyperreality; a reality in which we can be who we like, do what we want and, in one sense, live for ever (as long as no one pulls the plug of course…). And yet this triumph of the hyperreal is also its total ruination because it leaves us with a world totally devoid of meaning, a world of total nihilism, a world of trauma.

Welcome to the Real desert of the real…

Notes and references

  1. Or, as I prefer, the supposed subject of knowing: not only is there a supposition of knowledge but a supposition of the subject itself. ↑
  2. Leslie Chapman, Traumatic Neurosis Revisited: Drive-Jouissance and the Wounds of Life, The Palgrave Lacan Series (Palgrave Macmillan, 2025). ↑
  3. Not to be confused with the jouissance of the Other. ↑
  4. Jacques Lacan, The Other Side of Psychoanalysis: The Seminar of Jacques Lacan Book XVII, trans. Russell Grigg (W.W Norton and Co., 2007), 48. ↑
  5. Ibid., 50. ↑
  6. Sigmund Freud, ‘Beyond the Pleasure Principle’, in The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, XVIII (Hogarth Press, 1920)m 29, my italics. ↑
  7. Sigmund Freud, ‘Inhibitions, Symptoms and Anxiety’, in The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud (London: Hogarth Press, 1926), XX, 165-166. ↑
  8. Jean-Louis Gault, ‘Two Statuses of the Symptom: “Let Us Turn to Finn Again”’, in The Later Lacan: An Introduction, ed. Véronique Voruz and Bogdan Wolf (Sunny Press, 2007), 80. ↑
  9. Jacques-Alain Miller, ‘Is Feminine Jouissance Not Jouissance as Such?’, Lacanian Lnk, no. 55/56 (2021), 43-44. ↑
  10. Jacques-Alain Miller, ‘Six Paradigms of Jouissance’, Psychoanalytical Notebooks, no. 34 (December 2019), 61. ↑
  11. For a (reasonably) academic introduction to this process see: Nicholas J DeVito, Georgia C Richards, and Peter Inglesby, ‘How We Learnt to Stop Worrying and Love Web Scraping.’, Nature, 585.7826 (2020), 621–22. ↑
  12. John Johnston, The Allure of Machinic Life: Cybernetics, Artificial Life and the New AI (Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press, 2008) ↑
  13. For a useful and short introduction to the concept of media convergence see this paper: Sichach, Moses, Media Convergence and Artificial Intelligence: Transforming Communication and Content Creation (September 05, 2024). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4947632 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4947632 ↑
  14. See, for example: Jean Baudrillard, Simulacra and Simulation (The University of Michigan Press, 1994). ↑
  15. Although as Hans-George Moeller argues, what Baudrillard refers to as ‘simulation’ we would probably now refer to as ‘virtual reality’  or ‘virtualisation’:   Baudrillard on Simulacra and Simulation | with Georg Moeller of Carefree Wandering, directed by Johannes A. Niederhauser, 2023, 01:26:19, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tEc2VvqOKl4. ↑
  16. Baudrillard, Simulacra and Simulation, 79. ↑
  17. Jacques Lacan, The Seminar of Jacques Lacan Book XX 1972-1973: Encore, ed. Jacques-Alain Miller (WW Norton & Co, 1999), 23. ↑
  18. Miller, Six Paradigms of Jouissance, 69-70. ↑
  19. In her book of the same name Maria Tumarkin defines traumascapes as:…sites of terror attacks, natural and industrial catastrophes, genocide, exile, ecological degradation and communal loss of heart. Far from being mere backdrops to cataclysms, traumascapes hold the key to our ability to endure and find meaning in modern-day tragedies and the legacies they leave behind.Maria Tumarkin, Traumascapes: The Power & Fate of Places Transformed by Tragedy (Kindle Edition) (Penguin Books, 2005). ↑
  20. And, I would argue, this is also the case with Žižek. ↑

This article is part of a broader research project on The Algorithmic Other. For a complete overview of how Lacanian theory addresses the challenges of AI and digital simulation, please visit the AI and Psychoanalysis Hub.

As automated systems and algorithmic metrics increasingly format contemporary life and mental health, psychoanalysis provides an unscripted, human space to address what resists calculation. For those individuals who are navigating personal impasses or digtial burnout I can offer online consultations.  Please click here for further information.

One comment

  1. Guy Rittger

    The following reflections are offered in response to the core themes articulated in Trauma, Language, and the Real Limit of AI. I want to suggest that the instability characterized by Baudrillard as hyperreality is not simply an external “threat” brought about by new technologies, but rather a return of the repressed (wiederkehr des verdrängten) Real of the very foundation of human language as the site of the infinite and irrepressible play of potential meanings.

    The Primacy of Linguistic Instability
    The accelerating impact AI and LLMs are having on the proliferation of “hyperreality” and the blurring of boundaries between the authentic and the simulated appears, I would say, to be intrinsic to the very emergence and proliferation of language itself. This condition is most acutely realized with the advent of writing, which attempts to impose the constraints of a textual artifact upon the fluid nature of meaning.

    Language, in its function as a vehicle for converting raw data or information into meaning, necessarily relies on a foundational process of distillation and filtering. This selective nature is evidenced both by cognitive theory – insofar as the human organism is highly selective in the phenomena it intakes and processes – and by post-structuralist thought, where writing is shown to always involve an initial process of inclusion and exclusion. The consequence is that meaning, from its genesis, has always already been unstable, serving as an irrepressible site for the irruptions of the Real and jouissance. The entire critique of representational epistemology and its underlying ontological suppositions centers precisely on this inherent lack of stable correspondence.

    The Historical Foreclosure of Semantic Play
    If meaning is inherently fluid, then the stability of social systems depends on successfully limiting its play. Historically, this limitation is evidenced by the institutional management of interpretation. We see this plainly in the case of religious texts, which have traditionally served as anchors for secured truths but which themselves require “handlers” – priests, imams, or sages – to limit the perpetual threat of semantic slippage. Given the variety of meanings that can be derived from any written artifact, whether its origin be divine or human, the maintenance of systems of belief (and of social polity) hinges on this foreclosure, often enforced through the use of violence in the last instance.

    This perennial struggle between rhetoric and truth is also powerfully invoked by ancient philosophy. Plato’s Gorgias, for instance, directly engages with the Sophists regarding their use of rhetoric divorced from the truth, yet Socrates’ compelling critique itself relies on the reader accepting his premise regarding the knowability of “truth”. This premise ultimately depends on the ability to successfully affix meaning to information or phenomenon. While Socrates’ epistemological model is not strictly representational in the contemporary sense, it eventually runs into similar structural problems that continue to impact our present reality.

    The Modern Unveiling and Political Implications
    The history of modern Western thought, particularly since the 16th century, can be characterized as an effort to sweep this uncomfortable semantic reality under the carpet, even after the Protestant Reformation and the mass proliferation of printed copies of the Christian Bible effectively democratized interpretation, positing every person as their own reader and interpreter of God’s message, independent of institutional checks or other constraints on the proliferation of meanings. In this sense, the death of orthodoxies already profoundly presaged the hyper-pluralistic and self-referential Baudrillardian world we currently inhabit.

    The current moment, marked by the rapid advancement of generative AI, merely provides a spectacular (re)exposure of meaning as fundamentally fluid and language as an unbounded field of play. The critical question thus becomes: What does this mean from a political and ethical perspective?
    What is also being exposed in this moment is the structural dependence of political order on a controlled narrative. As official “meanings” or established orthodoxies lose their necessary effect of controlling the narrative, the underlying mechanism of constraint—namely, violence—is revealed as the final guarantor of stability. We are now seeing the emergence of this violence all around us as the control of meaning dissolves.

    In Short…
    As soon as language emerges – and with it the human subject – lived experience becomes a simulacrum of sorts. And the history of human evolution and civilization has been the history of managing the implications of the foundational instability of meaning, typically through pragmatic means but, when necessary, through the use of the violent foreclosure of meanings which are seen as threatening to societal cohesion. To me, one of the key values of AI is precisely the way in which it is exposing with increasing clarity the violence inherent in the perpetuation of existing systems of political, cultural and economic exploitation.

Comments are closed.