An impossible profession?
An impossible profession?

An impossible profession?

Here let us pause for a moment to assure the analyst that he has our sincere sympathy in the very exacting demands he has to fulfil in carrying out his activities. It almost looks as if analysis were the third of those ‘impossible’ professions in which one can be sure beforehand of achieving unsatisfying results. The other two, which have been known much longer, are education and government.[1]

This passage from Analysis Terminable and Interminable has long passed into psychoanalytic folklore and could almost be seen as a badge of honour worn amongst analysts; after all, what could be nobler and self-sacrificing then embarking on a path that you know in advance will end in failure? Of course, others might view such a ‘career choice’ as somewhat pathological; why would anyone embark on such an undertaking knowing it will inevitably end badly?

At this point it is instructive to look at what Freud wrote immediately prior to the above quoted passage: he is essentially arguing that the aspiring analyst must adhere to very high standards:

It is therefore reasonable to expect of an analyst, as part of his qualifications, a considerable degree of mental normality and correctness. In addition, he must possess some kind of superiority, so that in certain analytic situations he can act as a model for his patient and in others as a teacher. And finally we must not forget that the analytic relationship is based on a love of truth – that is, on a recognition of reality – and that it precludes any kind of sham or deceit.[2]

What’s particularly interesting, in my view, about these sentences is that they are not something Freud wrote at or near the beginning of his own analytic career, when he might perhaps be forgiven for what now appears to a hopelessly optimistic and somewhat naïve characterisation of the analyst. Rather, they were written in 1937, pretty much at the end of Freud’s life. Furthermore, such remarks seem to suggest that the ‘impossibility’ that Freud was referring to should not be taken too literally (or seriously); what he appears to be arguing is that the demands of analysis are very exacting, and it takes a special kind of person to meet them.

But what if, without perhaps fully realising it, Freud was right in a more fundamental sense regarding the ‘impossibility’ of psychoanalysis? Clearly, insofar there are people who practice psychoanalysis (or who would claim to be doing so), analysis is ‘possible’; although, of course, the fact that someone claims to be doing something doesn’t actually mean they are doing it. Perhaps Žižek, in his introduction to Gabriel Tupinambá’s The Desire of Psychoanalysis, is on to something when he asks:

Is not an analyst a subject/analysand who, within the analytic clinical setting, acts as if he is an analyst or even plays to be an analyst? The moment we substantialize the analyst, the moment we conceive him as a subject who is an analyst in himself, outside of the clinical setting, analysts become a new group of people of a special mold, made of a special stuff (as Stalin put it apropos Bolsheviks), and all the deadlocks of how to deal with a Master reappear.[3]

Perhaps this is precisely the mistake that Freud makes: he ‘substantializes’ the analyst as a person of exemplary qualities, rather than (the analyst) being the function of a particular kind of (transferential) relationship. However, this still doesn’t explain the ‘impossible’ dimension of psychoanalysis; even if the analyst is ‘faking it’ (to paraphrase Žižek) this does not mean analytic effects are not taking place.

But what of the relationship between psychoanalysis (and the psychoanalyst) and the Real? Is there something here that renders analysis ‘impossible’? After all, Lacan referred to the Real as the impossible, and the Real is something that all subjects (both analysts and analysands) will eventually stumble upon. Jean-Louis Gault argues that in the treatment of neurosis there is a trajectory from the Symbolic to the Real, whereas in psychosis the trajectory is reversed, that is, it goes from the Real to the Symbolic.[4] And Miller refers to “…bringing the subject back to his truly elementary signifiers, on which he has, in his neurosis, had a delusion.”[5] In other words, in both neurosis and psychosis there is an encounter with the Real within the analytic process; the only difference, perhaps, is that in the case of psychosis the encounter is at the beginning of the analysis whereas in neurosis it happens later on.

Even so, the idea of an encounter with the Real does not, it itself, render analysis ‘impossible’ – or does it? Although psychoanalysis can (and does) theorise, discourse on, the idea of an encounter with the Real, this is still done within the register of the Symbolic, of the discursive; and how else could it be? In other words, how else can psychoanalysis ‘speak’ of the Real, which is by definition the impossible to say? But what happens within analysis when the subject (and the analyst) actually runs into the Real? I would argue that it breaks down, is rendered impossible. At this moment, which may only last a few seconds or for a great deal longer, all the analyst can do is to bear witness to the subject’s (and their own) encounter with the Real.

Notes

  1. Sigmund Freud, ‘Analysis Terminable and Interminable’, in The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud (London: Hogarth Press, 1937), XXIII, 211–53, p.248. ↑
  2. Ibid., p.248. ↑
  3. Gabriel Tupinambá, The Desire of Psychoanalysis: Exercises in Lacanian Thinking, Kindle Edition (Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press, 2021), p.xii. ↑
  4. Jean-Louis Gault, ‘Two Statuses of the Symptom: “Let Us Turn to Finn Again”’, in The Later Lacan: An Introduction, ed. by Véronique Voruz and Bogdan Wolf (State of New York: Sunny Press, 2007), pp. 73–82. ↑
  5. Jacques-Alain Miller, ‘Interpretation in Reverse’, in The Later Lacan: An Introduction, ed. by Véronique Voruz and Bogdan Wolf (State of New York: Sunny Press, 2007),p. 7. ↑

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *